French Onion Soup

by Tokyo Terrace on September 30, 2009

I cannot believe that September is already coming to an end. It almost feels like I blinked and suddenly the weather became cooler. Even though Tokyo is still very humid, the temperature has become more comfortable. Still, I can’t help thinking about Minnesota at this time of year. The weather starts to get cold, the air is crisp and clear, and inside it feels cozy and warm. Cool autumn nights in Minnesota play out in my mind when I eat this soup.

I remember one of the first times that I had French onion soup. My mom would always serve the soup in little brown stoneware bowls. They are the kind of bowls you want to cup in your two hands just to let the heat radiate from the bowl into your hands, straight through to your core. Anyway, when I took my first bite of French onion soup, I was amazed by the savory flavor of the caramelized onions along with the perfectly melted cheese blanketing a piece of toasted bread. The textures, flavors, and aromas melt together to create what I feel is the perfect meal.

So, when I woke up this morning to rain and dark clouds, I knew it was the perfect day to make my own French onion soup. However,  though I love caramelizing onions the ‘right’ way (standing over the stove top for hours waiting for that perfect color and texture), I decided to try caramelizing the onions in the oven instead. Cooking the onions in the oven at 325 degrees F takes a similar amount of time, but requires less attention.

Start by slicing the onions thinly. Put the onions on a large baking sheet with sides at least 2” high. Top with pieces of butter, a little salt and dried thyme. Put the sliced onions in the oven on the center rack at 325 F for 2 1/2 hours, stirring them every twenty minutes or so.

I hope this recipe brings you the same feelings of warmth and comfort that it brought to us. What is your favorite comfort food?

French Onion Soup

Makes 4 servings

6 vidalia onions, thinly sliced

6 cups beef broth

2 tablespoons dried thyme

2 bay leaves

1 tablespoon sherry or dry white wine

4 slices Swiss/Emmental cheese

4 slices French or Italian bread, toasted

1/2 stick unsalted butter

2 tabelspoons flour

salt and black pepper to taste

Put the sliced onions on a large baking sheet. Sprinkle with the dried thyme, a small amount of salt and 1/2 of the butter (break off small pieces and scatter over the onions.) Place the baking sheet in the oven on the center rack at 325 degrees F for 2 1/2 hours. Be sure to stir the onions every 20 minutes, coating them with the melted butter.

When the onions have finished, take them out of the oven and set them aside. In a pan large enough to hold the soup, melt the remaining butter over medium high heat. When the butter is melted, add the caramelized onions to the pan and stir in the flour until it has soaked up the butter and the onions are coated (this will help thicken the soup slightly. Pour the beef broth over the onions and add the bay leaves. Cover and simmer for half an hour.

After the soup has simmered for half an hour, remove the bay leaves and add the sherry/white wine and salt and pepper to taste. Spoon the soup into 4 oven safe soup bowls. Place one piece of toasted bread on the top of each bowl and cover with a cheese slice. Set the bowls in the oven and heat under the broiler until the cheese is melted and begins to bubble and brown.

Serve immediately to friendly persons snuggled under warm blankets.

Share
  • http://www.sense-serendipity.blogspot.com/ Divina

    They look gorgeous Rachel. There’s nothing like French Onion Soup on a cold and cloudy day. It’s bright and sunny today so I will have to wait for a rainy (but no floods) day to make this soup.

  • http://www.sense-serendipity.blogspot.com Divina

    They look gorgeous Rachel. There’s nothing like French Onion Soup on a cold and cloudy day. It’s bright and sunny today so I will have to wait for a rainy (but no floods) day to make this soup.

  • http://cwfoodtravel.blogspot.com/ Borneoboy

    I love French Onion Soup. This looks lovely !

  • http://cwfoodtravel.blogspot.com/ Borneoboy

    I love French Onion Soup. This looks lovely !

  • Jan

    Beautiful! I think I’ll make this for your grandmother today.

  • Jan

    Beautiful! I think I’ll make this for your grandmother today.

  • cindy

    Great idea to caramelize in the oven. My Indian friends cook 10 or more onions at a time and then have a jar of them in the refrigerator to use as they are needed.

  • cindy

    Great idea to caramelize in the oven. My Indian friends cook 10 or more onions at a time and then have a jar of them in the refrigerator to use as they are needed.

  • Rachael Smith

    So I have never actually made French Onion Soup. I have to be honest I really tought you could only buy the Lipton Soup mix and use it for mixing with beef and other things to season it. So I am super excited that you published this recipe because it sounds soooooo good! It finally started to feel like fall here, it has been 70-80 the past couple of weeks! It frosted for the first time last night, so I think I am going to put your soup on the menu for tomorrow night! I hope all is well is Tokyo:)

  • Rachael Smith

    So I have never actually made French Onion Soup. I have to be honest I really tought you could only buy the Lipton Soup mix and use it for mixing with beef and other things to season it. So I am super excited that you published this recipe because it sounds soooooo good! It finally started to feel like fall here, it has been 70-80 the past couple of weeks! It frosted for the first time last night, so I think I am going to put your soup on the menu for tomorrow night! I hope all is well is Tokyo:)

  • http://dragonlife.wordpress.com/ dragonlife

    Dear Rachel!
    Greetings!
    As I said I’m not cold enough yet!LOL
    But next time, try adding a little dry white wine and som nutmeg!
    Cheers,
    Robert-Gilles

    http://shizuokagourmet.wordpress.com/
    (that is unles you want to read my fantasy blog!)

  • http://dragonlife.wordpress.com/ dragonlife

    Dear Rachel!
    Greetings!
    As I said I’m not cold enough yet!LOL
    But next time, try adding a little dry white wine and som nutmeg!
    Cheers,
    Robert-Gilles

    http://shizuokagourmet.wordpress.com/
    (that is unles you want to read my fantasy blog!)

  • http://kitchen-em.blogspot.com/ Kitchen M

    Looks delicious!! I’ve been waiting to make French Onion soup at home and your pictures finally convinced me to give it a try. Thanks for sharing the recipe!

  • http://kitchen-em.blogspot.com Kitchen M

    Looks delicious!! I’ve been waiting to make French Onion soup at home and your pictures finally convinced me to give it a try. Thanks for sharing the recipe!

  • http://kyotofoodie.com/ Michael

    I love French nion soup, but have never made it!

    So, you are an American foodie in Tokyo? I am an American foodie in Kyoto! And, I am from Minnesota. Are you too?

    Stop by either of my Kyoto sites and say hello!

    http://kyotofoodie.com
    http://openkyoto.com

  • http://kyotofoodie.com Michael

    I love French nion soup, but have never made it!

    So, you are an American foodie in Tokyo? I am an American foodie in Kyoto! And, I am from Minnesota. Are you too?

    Stop by either of my Kyoto sites and say hello!

    http://kyotofoodie.com
    http://openkyoto.com

  • http://jeroxie.com/addiction penny aka jeroxie

    I love the look of the cheese! And I have too many comfort foods that I like. The sup kambing that I made a few weeks ago is definitely one of them :)

  • http://jeroxie.com/addiction penny aka jeroxie

    I love the look of the cheese! And I have too many comfort foods that I like. The sup kambing that I made a few weeks ago is definitely one of them :)

  • http://thedabble.com/ Annie

    Indeed this would be perfect for a day like today in Minnesota. It is rainy/cool/and windy in the southern areas. I am definitely making this soon.

  • http://thedabble.com Annie

    Indeed this would be perfect for a day like today in Minnesota. It is rainy/cool/and windy in the southern areas. I am definitely making this soon.

  • Steven

    Unbelievable! Great recipe…and to think I was just about to start searching for a really good French Onion soup recipe today.
    I am going to surprise my wife with this one when she gets home!

  • Steven

    Unbelievable! Great recipe…and to think I was just about to start searching for a really good French Onion soup recipe today.
    I am going to surprise my wife with this one when she gets home!

  • http://workout-then-cook.blogspot.com/ Cookie

    I had no idea French Onion Soup took such a long time to make! I don’t think I could wait that long! hehe

  • http://workout-then-cook.blogspot.com Cookie

    I had no idea French Onion Soup took such a long time to make! I don’t think I could wait that long! hehe

  • Aunt J in Hendersonville

    Your onion soup pictures made my stomach growl. Yummm…
    Thanks for the recipe – and the reminder of how good onion soup is!

    Gorgeous weather here in TN (comfy days, cool nights)…

    You asked what is fave comfort food…
    Easy, darlin’ – a pot of ’soup beans’ (pinto, of course, and seasoned w/ham hock), a pone of hot cornbread, a diced vidalia…

    Split pea soup comes in second… :)

  • Aunt J in Hendersonville

    Your onion soup pictures made my stomach growl. Yummm…
    Thanks for the recipe – and the reminder of how good onion soup is!

    Gorgeous weather here in TN (comfy days, cool nights)…

    You asked what is fave comfort food…
    Easy, darlin’ – a pot of ’soup beans’ (pinto, of course, and seasoned w/ham hock), a pone of hot cornbread, a diced vidalia…

    Split pea soup comes in second… :)

  • http://bowlofmush.blogspot.com/ ABowlOfMush

    This is my favorite soup in the world!
    I’m drooling over yours!

  • http://bowlofmush.blogspot.com/ ABowlOfMush

    This is my favorite soup in the world!
    I’m drooling over yours!

  • http://cookingontheside.com/ Kathy – Cooking On the Side

    Your soup looks lovely! I think I ordered French Onion Soup about 5 times in restaurants this summer – have been on a bit of a kick. I’d love to make it myself soon.

  • http://cookingontheside.com Kathy – Cooking On the Side

    Your soup looks lovely! I think I ordered French Onion Soup about 5 times in restaurants this summer – have been on a bit of a kick. I’d love to make it myself soon.

  • http://jenacg-jen.blogspot.com/ Jen

    that looks amazing! with the glass of wine….perfect!

  • http://jenacg-jen.blogspot.com/ Jen

    that looks amazing! with the glass of wine….perfect!

  • tokyoterrace

    Divina: Thank you! It’s true, soup on a cold and cloudy day brings a lot of comfort and warmth.

    Borneoboy: Thanks for stopping by!

    Jan: I hope grandma likes it!

    Cindy: Thanks for stopping by and leaving a comment! That’s a great idea to make a large batch to use on short notice.

  • tokyoterrace

    Divina: Thank you! It’s true, soup on a cold and cloudy day brings a lot of comfort and warmth.

    Borneoboy: Thanks for stopping by!

    Jan: I hope grandma likes it!

    Cindy: Thanks for stopping by and leaving a comment! That’s a great idea to make a large batch to use on short notice.

  • tokyoterrace

    Rachael: Thanks for leaving a comment! I hope you will try this recipe and let me know how it goes. Maybe your kids will have the same great experience that I did when I was their age eating this delicious soup!

    Robert Guilles: Nutmeg sounds like a great addition to the soup! I will be sure to try that next time.

    Kitchen M: So glad to have you as a commenter on my blog! Also very pleased to see you on twitter. I hope you’ll try the recipe!

    Michael: Your sites look great! Where in MN are you from?

  • tokyoterrace

    Rachael: Thanks for leaving a comment! I hope you will try this recipe and let me know how it goes. Maybe your kids will have the same great experience that I did when I was their age eating this delicious soup!

    Robert Guilles: Nutmeg sounds like a great addition to the soup! I will be sure to try that next time.

    Kitchen M: So glad to have you as a commenter on my blog! Also very pleased to see you on twitter. I hope you’ll try the recipe!

    Michael: Your sites look great! Where in MN are you from?

  • tokyoterrace

    Jeroxie: The cheese is one of the best parts of this dish- the gooey, bubbly cheese makes it indulgent!

    Annie: I hope you try it!

    Steven: I hope your wife enjoys the soup! Your comment is probably one of the sweetest I’ve received- thanks for brightening my day!

    Cookie: French Onion Soup can take a long time, yes. But trust me, it is totally worth it to take the time to cook the onions. You can take the short cut and just soften them in a pan, but it does not result in the same sweet intense flavor.

  • tokyoterrace

    Jeroxie: The cheese is one of the best parts of this dish- the gooey, bubbly cheese makes it indulgent!

    Annie: I hope you try it!

    Steven: I hope your wife enjoys the soup! Your comment is probably one of the sweetest I’ve received- thanks for brightening my day!

    Cookie: French Onion Soup can take a long time, yes. But trust me, it is totally worth it to take the time to cook the onions. You can take the short cut and just soften them in a pan, but it does not result in the same sweet intense flavor.

  • tokyoterrace

    Aunt J: So glad to see you commenting again! I missed it!

    ABowlofMush: Glad you like the looks of it!

    Kathy: I order it all the time when the weather is not exactly cold. I love all the time!

    Jen: The wine certainly makes it better… :)

  • tokyoterrace

    Aunt J: So glad to see you commenting again! I missed it!

    ABowlofMush: Glad you like the looks of it!

    Kathy: I order it all the time when the weather is not exactly cold. I love all the time!

    Jen: The wine certainly makes it better… :)

  • http://wasabiprime.blogspot.com/ wasabi prime

    Aaaaaaahh! My kryptonite — melty, stringy cheese with onion soup! God bless the planet moving away from the sun for a few months so we can have a whole season of foods like this. As long as we move back towards the sun and we don’t wind up like that Twilight Zone episode.

  • http://wasabiprime.blogspot.com wasabi prime

    Aaaaaaahh! My kryptonite — melty, stringy cheese with onion soup! God bless the planet moving away from the sun for a few months so we can have a whole season of foods like this. As long as we move back towards the sun and we don’t wind up like that Twilight Zone episode.

  • http://mountaintimes.info/ Haley Destafino

    Hello,
    My name is Haley Destafino, I am the Associate Publisher of The Mountain Times, a weekly newspaper in Killington, Vermont. Every year we publish a summer and winter menu book which is a collection of the local restaurants menus. We look for colorful and seasonal photos for our covers and the photos you have are very appealing. I write to you in hopes of getting your permission to use one of them for this winter’s menu book cover. We would gladly give you the photo credit and copies after it is published. You can see this summers cover on our website, http://www.mountaintimes.info. I look forward to hearing from you. Thanks for your time.

  • http://mountaintimes.info Haley Destafino

    Hello,
    My name is Haley Destafino, I am the Associate Publisher of The Mountain Times, a weekly newspaper in Killington, Vermont. Every year we publish a summer and winter menu book which is a collection of the local restaurants menus. We look for colorful and seasonal photos for our covers and the photos you have are very appealing. I write to you in hopes of getting your permission to use one of them for this winter’s menu book cover. We would gladly give you the photo credit and copies after it is published. You can see this summers cover on our website, http://www.mountaintimes.info. I look forward to hearing from you. Thanks for your time.

Previous post:

Next post: